themexicandoctor
Senior Member
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2011
- Posts
- 1,619
Booster - this is for you in response to your Supersprings questions ...
Quiting below from Gerry Lambretti;
I agree with a lot of what “Booster” has to say below. However a couple of qualifiers.
1. The Solo Sumosprings essentially replace the factory bump-stop so are located at a node point on the sub frame that is specifically designed to accommodate the loadings. Because the spring curve of the Solo Sumosprings (jounce type Sumosprings) is progressive (parabolic spring curve) the Sumosprings comes in soft then gives rapid support. This offers a better transition for the wheel travel rather than freeboard then hard-stop. It provides a much nicer ride quality. Furthermore because of the high damping qualities of the Sumospring material it dissipates a lot of suspension energy.
2. The Coil Sumospring is different to the old coil spring rubber spacers as they have inherent spring properties that are progressive in nature coupled with the very helpful damping properties. The old spring rubber spacers were really an upgrade from a piece of two by four.
Hoping this is helpful. End Quote
Supersprings are an intersting company and have some nice stuff.
Personally, I don't like the idea of progressive bumpstop to increase front spring rate or height, as it puts the extra load on the wrong place in the suspension, eg the pivot bushing of the control arm and the arm itself. The will work, but I think aren't the best for durability if you can do it with springs.
I don't recall what we found out when we researched the Supercoils a while ago. Supersprings just gives the free length and "load" without what height that load would be at. Maybe someone remembers or can find the discussion that had the complete specs. I seem to remember them being a bit softer than the Moog 81006 and the same length. I do know they weren't considered a first choice.
The Sumocoils are just plain old coil spring rubber spacers that may have been updated a bit. Again, with the right springs, they should not be necessary, and the big thing about them is that because they somewhat immobilize part of the spring, the rest of the spring gets stressed more and will likely fatigue earlier.
Our vans run at nearly constant weight, with no big swings in how much weight is on any given wheel. For that reason, getting springs that are not progressive is a better idea than getting progressive. Progressive springs are made having smooth ride with light loads but still having the ability to carry heavy loads. If you use a progressive spring on a heavy, consistently loaded van, all that happens is the soft riding part gets compressed completely and the stiff section has to do all the work and is also less comfortable a ride. Putting all the stress in a smaller amount of the spring will cause faster fatigue. This is also one of the problems Erb had on his springs, as they were heavily progressive, and you saw what happened to yours, as I did in our testing.
As you can see, I am not a big fan of rubber helper springs or spacers. They will wear out way before most coil springs and they almost always are very progressive.
IMO, you will be way better off getting the correct springs for the height you want, and some good shocks. Use a stock height bump stop. I think you will be happy and also have a very reliable and consistent setup.
If you talk to Supersprings again, see if they will give you complete specs on their coil springs, so we can see where they would fit in your plan.
Quiting below from Gerry Lambretti;
I agree with a lot of what “Booster” has to say below. However a couple of qualifiers.
1. The Solo Sumosprings essentially replace the factory bump-stop so are located at a node point on the sub frame that is specifically designed to accommodate the loadings. Because the spring curve of the Solo Sumosprings (jounce type Sumosprings) is progressive (parabolic spring curve) the Sumosprings comes in soft then gives rapid support. This offers a better transition for the wheel travel rather than freeboard then hard-stop. It provides a much nicer ride quality. Furthermore because of the high damping qualities of the Sumospring material it dissipates a lot of suspension energy.
2. The Coil Sumospring is different to the old coil spring rubber spacers as they have inherent spring properties that are progressive in nature coupled with the very helpful damping properties. The old spring rubber spacers were really an upgrade from a piece of two by four.
Hoping this is helpful. End Quote