As usual Booster you make a very compelling case of how to fix this issue and makes perfect sense. On another note can you steer me in the right direction of brakes. I read a thread the other day where you talked about metallic pads and grooved rotors but I cannot remember where to find that one?
Thanks
You would probably be able to find the threads by searching using the advanced search, search by thread starter, booster, with both places checked to show results as threads. There are quite a few pages of them, but the easiest way to find them as the search here often doesn't work well. That is how I would find them.
Bottom line is to use top of the line semi-metallic pads, some are rated as "police" compound even. Hawk had always been my preference, but there has been some concern about rivet failures on them. Peteco had a thread on that. We have heard good results with the major brands like Raybestos, Wagner, Bendix if they still are doing the high end semi metallics.
The rotor information has also been trickling in over time and it appears the original guess of high quality rotors with small slots in a random pattern may be the best choice, but nobody makes them anymore. Most have bigger slots in them so probably not as good because of reduced mass and area, but the ones with least slot area are probably good and not a problem. We have also had quite few reports of plain rotors doing just fine, which is also not surprising as on the test I have seen didn't indicate the slots and hole is rotors don't do much if anything for cooling, only pad cleaning. Good quality aggressive semi metallics tend to not need as much cleaning. Even stock Chevy rotors seem to work OK for people, and I think would always be OK on the rear, and probably on the front as long as they run true. I don't know if there have been any changes in the Chevy rotors over the years, though, as stuff like that does happen often. IMO, the big thing to stay away from is any rotor with holes as they don't do much if anything and can cause cracking.
The pads have turned out to be, I think by a large margin, the biggest issue in the juddering problem that has been seen by many of us, but goes away with good pads. Don't let any brake guy tell you it is heat warping of the rotors that goes straight when the cool down, as that is not the cause of the juddering. It is caused by the uneven material transfer to the rotors from ceramic pads that GM used.
If you do the brakes yourself, be sure to find Peteco's writeup on the correct grease for the guides pins and boots as the old "brake grease" will ruin the new rubber compound the use now, so only silicone like Silgyde should be used. I had to redo all the rubber parts in those areas in two vehicles, including the Roadtrek, after that discussion, and yes all the rubber parts were damaged by the grease.